Almost every commercial carpet job comes down to this one choice, and for most fit-outs the tiles win — not because they look better, but because of what happens after they are laid.
Replacement. One stained or worn tile lifts out and a new one goes in. With broadloom, damage in a walking lane means replacing the run, and matching dye lots years later is difficult. Buying a box of spares at the start is normal practice, and it is what turns a disaster into a ten-minute job.
Cabling. Where power and data run under a raised access floor, tiles let you lift a square, reach the service and put it back. Broadloom over an access floor largely defeats the point of having one.
Waste and access. Tiles carry offcuts around columns and odd corners with far less waste, they arrive in boxes a person can carry up a lift, and they can be laid room by room around a working office rather than closing the floor.
Where broadloom still wins: large uninterrupted areas where a seamless expanse is the point — function rooms, hotel corridors, boardrooms, quiet floors. It is softer underfoot and there is no grid to read, and in a space designed to feel calm that is a real difference.
Carpet plank sits between the two: the replaceability of tiles in a long rectangular format that suits corridors and directional layouts, and it reads less like a grid.